Jump to content
HWBOT Community Forums

Antinomy

Crew
  • Posts

    1987
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    53

Posts posted by Antinomy

  1. This was discussed quite a number of times. I've suggested this one in 2007 and I'm pretty sure that I wasn't the first one.

     

    I want to argue on a complication:

    3Dmark06 - HD4870 competition

     

    1st: Bencher 1 (Team A)

    2nd: Bencher 2 (Team B)

     

    Bencher 1 lends his golden HD4870 to 10 other benchers of his team. The ranking will look as follows:

     

    1st: Bencher 1 (team A)

    2nd: Bencher 3 (team A)

    3rd: Bencher 4 (team A)

    4th: ...

    ...: ...

    11th: Bencher 2 (team B).

     

    The amount of points added to the team's total of the submission of bencher 2 is now a lot lower because of the hardware sharing.

    Massman, if I post 20 results on one piece of hardware in one benchmark and a guy posts a worse score - he'll get like if he was 21st or 2nd? ;) why do you judge of the new rules within the old ones? If it's "best result scored" the 2nd till 10th won't matter like it's now with personal scores.

     

    As for the second - yes, such situation makes it harder for the novice but this will shift the situation like it was with rev. 2 - more people will go to old-school since it's easier to grab scores there. They'll bring a big variety of categories, not like it's now - "Get an i7 rig, and plug as much G80, G92, RV770, RV870 as you can and you'll get more boints than this guy ever see even with his amount of CPUs".

     

    I hope you follow my mind :)

     

    Yes, a novice won't get scores on a stock 4870, but how much can he make in 3DMark01 on stock now? ;)

    Is the situation really going to get worse? No, it's going to get different. Newcomers won't try to get hot hardware in order to make the category even more hot but they'll more likely get less popular one and improve their skills in such a sandbox.

     

    It's just an answer on your arguments, I don't say this way is perfect - it obviously isn't like many others are too.

  2. First of all, we have a staff of moderators to ensure that whoever is moderating is not doing it because of personal/team objectives, but to keep HWBOT clean.
    LOL on that :)

     

    And by better I mean: less cheaters, but also not making it extremely complex and slow. We want to remove cheaters, but not by making the validation process 10x longer.
    Agree on that. And there are such ways, you know. I've written you a number of times on this as I remember.
×
×
  • Create New...