Jump to content
HWBOT Community Forums

Taloken

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    240

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Taloken

    [Suggest] Submit pre-validation by captains

    in HWBOT Development: bugs, features and suggestions

    Posted

    Good morning all !

     

     

    I noticed in my team a certain number of reported submissions.

     

    It's mainly caused by incorrect screenshot, because the user didn't take care of general benchmark rules or special competition rules.

     

    It brings a removing of the contest or of the rankings, then the user have to redo his run etc ...

    And discouragement come.

     

     

    I totally agree that rules maintain a sportsmanship in Hwbot, and i don't criticize the actual system, on the contrary i like how it's strict but not like the final judgement.

     

     

    How about a pre-validation of submits by team's captain ?

     

    Explanation :

    1. The user submit its score like it's now, no changes.

    2. The team's captain is noticed (Mod Tools, email if chosen) of a submit pending for validation.

    3a. If the submit is correct, the captain valid it and it's added to the rankings.

    3b. If the submit is incorrect, it's blocked like after a moderation action, and the captain see with his mate what's wrong.

     

    This feature would be enabled or disabled in the Team Account panel, choice of captains. The minimal League which is controlled would be adjustable (Only rookies, novice and lower, enthusiasts and lower ...).

     

     

     

    This way, the rankings would be less polluted by incorrect submits, without asking the moderators to triple their working time.

     

     

     

     

    Aaannd what about members without teams ? They chose to bench solo, so I think they have to be rigorous by themselves.

     

     

     

    Thank you for noticing my suggestion, i'm open to discussion :)

     

     

    Taloken

    Team Cowcotland

    FR

     

     

    PS : Excuse-me if it's in the wrong sub-forum, a quick search didn't return me similar threads.

    The official OC4DOGE thread.

    in HWBOT Competitions

    Posted · Edited by Taloken

    It's """difficult""" for rookies to take care of reglementations.

    We (my team's captains) repeat regularly the submission rules, explaining the reason of reports without systematically press the red button... there is work xD

     

     

     

    Edit : Yeah i didn't take for myself, just a global remark ^^ i totally agree the reglementation system of Hwbot.

    The official HWBOT Team Cup 2014 - SC4: MISC Challenge thread.

    in HWBOT Competitions

    Posted · Edited by Taloken

    There is this one : http://hwbot.org/submission/2583096_

    I thought it was just an occasionnal error and Ney validated the submit for the stage manually.

     

    And recently this one :

    http://hwbot.org/submission/2585228_

     

    For both i tried to edit them as a team capitain, but never could insert them to the Team Cup. Seems like it's particular to the HWBot Prime Androïd submissions.

     

     

     

    Edit : Same thing for Team Cup SC3 stages :/

×
×
  • Create New...