This guy seems to steal screens / results

[mAlkAv!An]

Today I just realized that a new user joined my team, http://hwbot.org/community/user/r0ony?tab=profile

 

All his scores seemed ok but one was out of the line. As he just used air/water cooling for all his results I wondered alot how he was able to reach 5.7GHz with a QX9650

 

This is 'his' score:

http://hwbot.org/community/submission/1054137_r0ony_3dmark_2006_2x_radeon_hd_3870_x2_32601_marks

 

Here's obviously the original from elmor:

http://hwbot.org/community/submission/931226_elmor_3dmark_2006_2x_radeon_hd_3870_x2_32601_marks

[Thor941]

I have removed the entry

 

you should ban him from your team

[mAlkAv!An]

I've already did before posting this

[Christian Ney]

A question How did he get the pic as there is no media on elmor's submission ?

[Christian Ney]

Maybe he really stolen it

[Thor941]

A question How did he get the pic as there is no media on elmor's submission ?

 

forums

[mAlkAv!An]

I think so too. He possibly just browsed through some old threads at XS & Co.

Perhaps he felt more safe as elmor didn't attached a screen, besides the submission was made for a single 3870X2 initially so that both results aren't listed next to each other.

 

Btw, he just joined the next team now :D:D

[Hyperhorn]

Ok, so someone - let's say it was in July 2010 for better imagination - recieves a score from a well-known overclocker, is publishing it at an online competition and gets banned from Hwbot for a year and someone else steals a score from a well-known overclocker after the whole community was going mad about this fictional *cough* score sharing just a few weeks ago, is publishing it at hwbot directly and NOTHING happens anymore?

 

All Fool's day twice this year?

 

Edit: That's exactly the reason why I tag every score I upload somewhere - to prevent unnecessary things going to happen

Edited September 17, 2010 by Hyperhorn

[Hollywood]

I think so too. He possibly just browsed through some old threads at XS & Co.

Perhaps he felt more safe as elmor didn't attached a screen, besides the submission was made for a single 3870X2 initially so that both results aren't listed next to each other.

 

Btw, he just joined the next team now :D:D

 

Guess so too. Just kick him out!

[1Day]

Theft of someone else's benchmark results is a banning offence as far as I am concerned - has anyone contacted the member to ask for his version yet?

 

This nub has to go.

[BenchZowner]

Theft of someone else's benchmark results is a banning offence as far as I am concerned - has anyone contacted the member to ask for his version yet?

 

This nub has to go.

 

Exactly.

Score stealing should result in instant ban.

No questions asked ( I mean in cases where we are 100% sure of who stole the score ).

[mAlkAv!An]

Easiest way to determine would be to ask elmor if this is his screen

Nevertheless gpu clocks are the same, graphics vendor, motherboard plus the frames(2 decimal places) of all 6 subtests

 

He just entered the 3rd team in a row now

[TaPaKaH]

here's the original XS thread

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=183539

[Thor941]

he is ban

[RoccoESA]

he is ban

 

... and back as "pocoloco"

 

http://hwbot.org/community/user/pocoloco

 

http://hwbot.org/community/submission/1055987_pocoloco_3dmark_2006_mobility_radeon_hd_3650_3446_marks is identically

[mAlkAv!An]

Yeah, all submitted hardware is identically. Some results are the same, some has been rebenched but still very close ...

He has got the exact same amount of hwboints, too.

[pocoloco]

Hi,

at the time to clarify the screenshot I've had for several months on my hard drive and could not remember where I got him and I'm sorry I uploaded a screenshot of is not from me. I wanted to aim at nothing bad, I was not so clear about the rules, because my english is not the best. Because of my screenshot was one of about 35 not mine, I beg you therefore to give me a warning instead of a ban. I did not fraudsters, but only a beginner of an error!

 

r0ony aKa PocoLoco

[pocoloco]

Hi,

at the time to clarify the screenshot I've had for several months on my hard drive and could not remember where I got him and I'm sorry I uploaded a screenshot of is not from me. I wanted to aim at nothing bad, I was not so clear about the rules, because my english is not the best. Because of my screenshot was one of about 35 not mine, I beg you therefore to give me a warning instead of a ban. I did not fraudsters, but only a beginner of an error!

 

r0ony aKa PocoLoco

 

I´m sorry

 

3DMark06 submission rules

 

"It is your responsibility, and the responsibility of your team captain(s) that these

rules are followed properly. Your submission may be blocked by hwbot crew without

notice if your submission is in violation of one of these rules. Multiple infractions may

lead to a warning, and eventually an account ban."

[Christian Ney]

I´m sorry

 

3DMark06 submission rules

 

"It is your responsibility, and the responsibility of your team captain(s) that these

rules are followed properly. Your submission may be blocked by hwbot crew without

notice if your submission is in violation of one of these rules. Multiple infractions may

lead to a warning, and eventually an account ban."

 

You have to know if you bench on LN2 or not. And if you have ever had this rig

[pocoloco]

You have to know if you bench on LN2 or not. And if you have ever had this rig

 

rig ?

[Christian Ney]

rig ?

 

Bench system, components you used